What actually happens in a mediation session, step by step
If you have never mediated before, the unknown can feel bigger than the dispute itself. Here is the whole arc of a session, stage by stage, so you know what to expect before you say a word.
Stage one: convening
Before anyone talks about the dispute, there is setup. Convening is the quiet groundwork. The mediator confirms who will attend, agrees on the time, and makes sure the space works for everyone. For online mediation, that space is a Zoom link, so you can join from wherever you feel steady and comfortable.
This is also when the ground rules get set. How you will take turns. How long you have. What stays private. Getting this clear early takes a lot of the tension out of the room. If you want to walk in ready, here is how to prepare for a session.
Run your own numbers
See a rough comparison for your situation in about a minute.
Open the savings toolStage two: the mediator's opening
Once everyone is present, the mediator opens. This short statement explains how the session will run and what the mediator's role is. You will hear the same idea stated plainly. The mediator is neutral, does not take sides, and will not decide who is right.
The opening also covers confidentiality, which is one of the reasons people speak freely in mediation. What you say here is protected, with only a few narrow exceptions. If that matters to you, and it does to most people, read how confidentiality works.
Stage three: each person's statement
Now you talk. Each person gets uninterrupted time to describe the situation as they see it and what they hope to work out. No cross-talk. No rushing.
This part does quiet, important work. Often it is the first time each person has heard the other out without the conversation turning into an argument. The mediator listens for what sits underneath the words, the needs and concerns driving each request, and reflects them back so both of you feel heard.
Stage four: setting the agenda
With both stories on the table, the mediator helps turn them into a working list. This is the agenda. It names the specific issues to sort out, in language that belongs to neither person.
A clear agenda changes the whole feel of the room. Instead of one large, heavy conflict, you have a set of concrete topics to move through together. The problem sits out in front of you both, and you get to face it side by side rather than across from each other.
Stage five: problem-solving
This is the heart of the session, and usually the longest part. You work through the agenda one item at a time.
The mediator helps you brainstorm options, weigh them, and reality-test them against what each of you actually needs. Some ideas get set aside. Others get reshaped until they fit. The aim is not to prove anyone wrong. It is to find terms that both of you can accept and keep.
When a caucus helps
Sometimes the conversation needs a private turn. A caucus is a one-on-one, confidential conversation between the mediator and one person, while the other waits. It can help when feelings are running high, when someone wants to test an idea before saying it out loud, or when a private worry is easier to name alone. Here is more on what a caucus is and how it moves things forward.
Stage six: the agreement
When you reach terms that work, the mediator helps put them in writing. You read it over, adjust the wording until it is right, and sign. That written agreement is the record of what you decided together.
Most sessions get here. Research puts the settlement rate at roughly 70 to 80 percent, though every case is its own. And if you settle only part of what you came in with, you still leave with less to carry.
A session with Salt City Mediation runs online, at $200 an hour plus a $35 admin fee, with a two-hour minimum. Want to see if it fits? Book a free consult and we will talk it through, with no obligation.
David
Founder of Salt City Mediation and of EmpathEase, an app for practicing empathy and Nonviolent Communication. Completing Utah's court mediation training.